Detroit Tigers’ Casey Mize chased in 10-3 loss, as Indians’ Shane Bieber dominates

Detroit Free Press

Cleveland Indians right-handed starter Shane Bieber wanted to continue pitching in the eighth inning against the Detroit Tigers.

Interim manager Sandy Alomar Jr. tried to pull him after 7⅔ scoreless in a 10-run game, but Bieber — over 110 pitches — refused to depart. The next batter, Willi Castro, lined a three-run homer to put the Tigers on the board.

At that point, Bieber had no choice but to exit. But Castro’s blast didn’t matter Thursday at Comerica Park. Not when the likely AL Cy Young winner with a 1.74 ERA bulldozed past the Tigers with 10 strikeouts.

The Tigers were nearly held scoreless for the second game in a row. On Thursday, it was a 10-3 defeat to the Indians, who improved to 27-23 overall and snapped an eight-game losing skid.

With the loss, Detroit (21-28) is five games behind the Toronto Blue Jays for the AL’s eighth and final playoff spot. The Indians have a half-game lead on the Blue Jays for seventh place.

[ How the Tigers can rejoin playoff hunt with a big weekend ]

The Tigers continue the four-game series with right-hander Michael Fulmer starting Friday, followed by righty Spencer Turnbull on Saturday and lefty Matthew Boyd on Sunday. The Indians counter with Zach Plesac, Triston McKenzie and Carlos Carrasco.

See ya, splitter

After taking a no-hitter into the sixth inning in his Sept. 11 start against the power-hitting Chicago White Sox, Mize seemed ready to put together back-to-back strong outings for the first time in his six-game career.

He gave up a two-out solo homer to Jose Ramirez on an 86.5 mph splitter in the first inning. The pitch never dropped, and Ramirez sent it over the right-field wall for a 1-0 lead on his 28th birthday. Mize responded by taking down the next seven Indians, pushing through the third inning at 41 pitches.

But Cleveland chased him in the top of the fourth.

Ramirez crushed his second home run of the game (and his 13th this year) on a 95.1 mph fastball, driving in two runs for a 3-0 lead. Five batters and two outs later, third baseman Isaac Paredes made an error with the bases loaded. He could’ve smoothly fielded a grounder from Oscar Mercado and stepped on third base, but he swiped aggressively at the ball — which bounced off his glove and into foul territory to allow another run and keep the inning alive for the Indians.

Tigers manager Ron Gardenhire pulled Mize after he walked Francisco Lindor with the bases loaded, putting the Tigers in the hole by five runs.

Mize ended with five runs (three earned) on four hits and three walks with one strikeout in 3⅔ innings. More surprising than the rocky start was his lack of offspeed command. Of his 79 pitches, he used 41% sinkers, 25% four-seam fastballs, 16% cutters, 13% splitters and 5% curveballs.

All four of his swinging strikes — and six of eight called strikes — came from his fastball.

Ramirez improves

Left-hander Nick Ramirez inherited a bases-loaded, two-out jam and wiggled out of it with three pitches — 86.5 mph fastball and repeat 79.2 mph changeups — to get Cesar Hernandez to strikeout swinging. 

In each of Ramirez’s two outings since being called up from the alternate training site in Toledo, he allowed two runs in two innings. He took a step forward Thursday with one walk and no hits in 2⅓ innings.

Same ol’ Zimm

Right-hander Jordan Zimmermann made the second relief appearance in his 12-year career. His last time was Sept. 26, 2016, against the Royals.

On Thursday, he wasn’t much help in the seventh and eighth innings.

Zimmermann gave up five runs on six hits and one walk in 1⅔ innings. He was replaced by Rony Garcia with two outs in the eighth and a runner on first base. His fastball maxed out at 90.8 mph but averaged 88.5 mph. Of his 48 pitches, he tossed 14 two-seamers, 13 four-seamers, eight sliders, seven curveballs and six changeups.

What’s up with Daz?

Gardenhire gave right fielder Daz Cameron a break Wednesday, moving Jorge Bonifacio to right field and having Travis Demeritte play left field. Cameron made his MLB debut Sept. 9 and is now off to a 1-for-27 start.

“Giving Daz a chance to regroup a little bit,” Gardenhire said Thursday afternoon.

He delivered in a 4-3 loss to the Chicago White Sox on Sept. 11 with a two-run single, but hasn’t done much else other than strikeout 11 times and walk once. Cameron returned to Thursday’s lineup with a .042 batting average and went 0-for-3 with one strikeout.

[ Detroit Tigers’ Daz Cameron’s first MLB hit: Like father, like son, 25 years later ]

Gardenhire diagnosed the problem as simply trying too hard.

“He’s trying so hard to get hits, and that’s probably why he’s not getting hits,” Gardenhire said. “He’s a little worried about it, but this is the big leagues. We face good pitchers.”

Evan Petzold is a sports reporting intern at the Detroit Free Press. Contact him at or follow him on Twitter @EvanPetzold. The Free Press has started a new digital subscription model. Here’s how you can gain access to our most exclusive Detroit Tigers content. 

Articles You May Like

Is Detroit Pistons’ max contract extension deal with Cade Cunningham the right move?
Six day two 2024 MLB draft prospects who could interest the Tigers
Pennsylvania Lottery Online Plays
Tigers select SS Bryce Rainer with their first pick of the 2024 MLB Draft
Guardians 9, Tigers 8 (10 innings): Big comeback falls a little short

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *